Fairplay CRA FYI Episode 5 featuring Escario and Hogan
Fairplay CRA FYI Episode 5 featuring Escario and Hogan

CRA Proposed Rule: Grant Limits, Asset Thresholds & More

In the fifth installment of FairPlay’s CRA / FYI podcast series, host Abby Hogan, FairPlay general counsel, welcomes Rebecca Escario, managing director at CrossCheck Compliance.

Escario has more than 25 years of experience helping banks, mortgage companies, credit unions, fintechs, and trust companies with consumer protection laws and regulatory expectations, including about 15 years advising clients on the Community Reinvestment Act. She leads CrossCheck’s fair lending practice, where her CRA work includes community credit needs assessments, CRA strategic plans, and exam preparation. Before joining CrossCheck, she was the operating officer at ADI Compliance Consulting.

The two discuss the notice of proposed rulemaking issued by the OCC and FDIC, including the revised asset-size thresholds, the 15% overhead limit on CRA grants, the treatment of deposit access products, and the Federal Reserve’s absence from the proposal. Escario also covers the proposal’s expanded access to CRA strategic plans and her advice to banks as they plan for possible changes.

Watch the Episode

Time Stamps

00:00 Introduction and Rebecca Escario’s background

02:54 How Rebecca Escario got into compliance consulting

06:05 CRA investments that serve LMI communities

11:07 Hiring and talent in underserved markets

12:11 How banks should plan for the CRA proposed rule

15:56 Asset-size thresholds and data collection

18:07 Winners and losers: community banks and the 15% grant cap

22:45 If Rebecca wrote the rule: deposit access products

27:07 The Federal Reserve and possible legal challenges

29:38 What no one is talking about: CRA strategic plans

Transcript

Abby Hogan, General Counsel, FairPlay: Hello and welcome to our FairPlay podcast on the Community Reinvestment Act. We’ve been joined for several weeks now by a number of really incredible, knowledgeable guests, and this week is no exception. I’m so excited to introduce one of our longtime friends of FairPlay, Rebecca Escario from CrossCheck Compliance. So I have a little bio I’ll read off here, and then we’ll dig into some questions and learning more from Rebecca.

Rebecca Escario is a managing director at CrossCheck Compliance, a nationwide consulting firm serving the financial services industry. She has more than 25 years of experience helping banks, mortgage companies, credit unions, fintechs, and trust companies navigate consumer protection laws and regulatory expectations. Rebecca leads CrossCheck’s fair lending practice, with a particular focus on both fair lending and the Community Reinvestment Act and its strategy for banks and fintechs.

Her CRA work includes helping banks assess community credit needs, develop CRA strategic plans, and prepare for examinations. She helps institutions connect their business models with opportunities to serve their communities and translate regulatory requirements into practical, measurable goals. Before joining CrossCheck, Rebecca was the operating officer at ADI Compliance Consulting, where she directed regulatory compliance projects involving CRA, fair lending, HMDA, UDAP, and AML/CFT.

Rebecca is a frequent instructor and presenter for banking and mortgage associations and financial institutions across the country. She brings a practical perspective to evolving CRA and fair lending issues and is one of my favorite people to work with. So, such a joy to have her here. Welcome to the podcast, Rebecca.

Rebecca Escario, Managing Director, CrossCheck Compliance: Thank you. Thank you so much. I’m so happy to be here, Abby. Very happy to be here.

Abby Hogan: Thanks. So let’s just dig right in. Tell us a little bit about how long you’ve been advising clients on the Community Reinvestment Act. How long have you been in this world?

Rebecca Escario: Sure. So, as you stated in my bio, I’ve been in the industry for over 25 years, but I would say specifically advising clients on the Community Reinvestment Act, probably for about 15 solid years now, in some way, shape, or form. And I know at CrossCheck here, which I’ve been with just about two and a half years now, I would have to say that these past two and a half or three years, we’ve really ramped up, and it has been the most active. At least I personally have been, and I think the firm also, most active with clients and their CRA consulting needs, for sure.

Abby Hogan: Great. Was this something that you always knew you wanted to work on in terms of CRA and fair lending? When people asked little Rebecca in grade school, “What do you want to be when you grow up?” and someone said firefighter, someone said police officer, did you say, “I want to be a fair lending expert”? Or how did you get here?

Rebecca Escario: Okay. I think I said what a lot of kids maybe in the seven, eight, nine-year-old age range said: “I want to be a veterinarian,” or “I want to work with animals,” or something like that. And I’ll be honest, I don’t know about you, but I’m not sure I’ve met anyone who actually said at that age, “I want to be a compliance officer,” or “I want to consult on CRA or fair lending.” Even in college. I mean, I’m dating myself a little bit, but there were no courses for this. No one was like, “I want to work at a bank and be a compliance officer.”

So, I sort of fell into it, like I feel many people in the industry I know did as well. And how I came about it definitely wasn’t very exciting. It wasn’t very flashy. But it might be a little unique, just because I have always been on the consulting side in this industry.

So, you meet a lot of people that were former bankers, examiners, like yourself, or working at one of the local or federal agencies, or in a financial institution in some aspect. I sort of came out of the gate and landed with a regulatory compliance consulting firm right out of college. So I do think that was a little bit unique, and I just fell in love with the consulting aspect of it, working with all different types of financial institutions, and have just stayed with it ever since. I came out of school with communications and marketing, began working for the firm, and then just gravitated towards compliance consulting.

Abby Hogan: I feel like I hear that a lot in anything in the banking ecosystem. No one thought from a young age they were going to be a banker or any sort of compliance person, or even consulting. But once you step a foot into that industry, I don’t see a ton of people leaving it. I think it’s a pretty enjoyable, intellectually stimulating place to work.

Rebecca Escario: Yeah, and definitely not leaving it, but maybe just changing roles. Maybe they start in a bank and then move to an examination role, move to an agency, go back to a financial institution, or consulting. So, there are lots of different options within the industry, the role that you can play.

Abby Hogan: And the CRA world is this really fascinating niche that I think a lot of us end up in. It’s a very do-gooder area of banking, where a lot of it is very profit-motivated. The CRA is this cool space of how can we find this win-win for banks and for communities and everyone in between. Do you have any personal stories of some of your interactions in the CRA space? Of ways that you’ve been able to help clients, or you’ve observed other bankers be able to get investments into some of these underserved communities?

Rebecca Escario: As far as personal stories, yeah, like so many, we do work with financial institutions across the country with different aspects of their CRA programs, whether it’s wanting to prep for an exam, or wanting help for qualifying loans, things like that. But we do hear good stories and learn good stories from time to time. One recent one, I’ll keep it high level.

If we’re talking about how they’re really impacting the community, there’s always the lending and there’s always the service. Institutions and personnel and staff at banks can get very creative with service. I think the list goes on and on there. But I think the past couple of years, we’ve seen some of our clients get more creative with their investments as well.

One example: when we have clients who serve underserved markets, if you will, in urban areas, real estate investments. So if we’re talking about investments now, real estate investments that really go beyond profit for the bank, and there is a purpose for them purchasing, let’s say, an apartment building. We see that often in urban areas. Let’s just say an apartment building that serves low- to moderate-income residents. You think about that, the bank thinks about that as an investment, of course, a good business choice, because their business choices should really always be aligning, or CRA should be aligning with business strategy.

But then they dig deeper and find out how retaining, in this case, an apartment complex can go so much further. It keeps those low- to moderate-income residents closer to their jobs. It keeps the children closer to their schools. It creates jobs in the area. So we see a lot of success from our clients who look at investments like that, not just, “Okay, is this a good business choice? What’s our margin going to be on this?” But “How can we support the community by making this purchase, by making this investment, or this loan in some cases, that’s going to support something like that?”

And just recently, we’ve seen mixed-use cases of investments too. So they go beyond; they serve multiple purposes. Again, I’m going to use an apartment complex, but it could be a condo. In urban areas, we usually see the former. It’s mixed-use real estate investments that serve a deeper CRA strategic purpose. So you have residences, and then sometimes you’ll have, let’s say, an urgent care facility on site, or you will have a pharmacy on site, or you’ll have other business purposes for the residential property as well that serve the LMI community in those ways as well. And so it’s a win-win for everyone. And so some of our clients have really found a sweet spot, if you will, that helps them serve the underserved communities, but also helps them with their strategic growth as well.

Abby Hogan: Yeah, I see that time and again. And my experience working in a bank, too, is the employment side. A lot of banks struggle with getting a diversity of different backgrounds and perspectives in their staffing. And so my personal experience has also been that getting into some of these communities that might not be at the top of a bank’s radar to start with also lends to this other employment piece of, “We’re not operating in this community. We should be doing more. And we’ve been overlooking this whole talent pool, too.” And so often it brings in some really great talent with new, fresh perspectives that banks haven’t been considering. So not only is the community getting this great investment, not only are the people on the other side of this investment feeling that directly, then you’re also integrating the bank into the places where they’re located, where their branches are, or in some of the neighborhoods where they might not have their headquarters.

Rebecca Escario: Absolutely.

Abby Hogan: That’s great. So, turning for a moment over to the proposed rule that came out just a few months back, how have you been thinking about the proposal and how it might impact some of your clients?

Rebecca Escario: Yeah, so it’s really an understatement to say that it hasn’t caused a little bit of a stir, and we get lots of questions and have been working with our clients. Our general advice for our approach with this new proposed rulemaking is, for the time being at least (and I’m sure we might get a little bit into what could change, what may not change, et cetera), just keep CRA as an ongoing part of your business plan. That’s our number one, first and foremost advice to our clients.

But there is absolutely no harm in planning according to what the new rulemaking might change. Even some of the granular details of what might change in the rule don’t change the core of CRA, like the community needs assessment, understanding where your bank or institution (if you’re state-regulated for CRA as well) where could make the most meaningful impact. Those two things should always stay at the center.

And another thing that we always say, and it goes along with some of these things that we’re seeing in the new rulemaking, is just listen. Listen to community stakeholders. They’re going to play an important part, especially as strategic plans perhaps become more accessible to banks. And they’re going to play an equally, if not more, important part if perhaps under the new rulemaking those CD activities aren’t measured exactly as they are now. I know there’s lots of debate about that, but I think it’s going to become almost increasingly important to have a pulse on your community stakeholders and have that line of communication with them.

But really, I think our message today, what we’ve been sharing with clients, is keep managing according to the requirements today. We don’t know exactly what’s going to happen. We can talk a little bit about what we think may be coming down the pipeline. But stay the course now, and start looking at what changes could mean for your institution. Start putting together some numbers. Could we be changing a bank size category? Could we no longer need to report certain fields? Just start thinking about how that would look, where there might be gaps in your program, and just cautiously plan right now, is basically what we’re sharing with clients.

Abby Hogan: That’s great advice. And some of the changes, to your point, there are more nuances than you would initially read. I think a lot of folks, when they read the proposed rule, thought one of the biggest changes was going to be these asset-size threshold modifications, moving the different tests that different banks would be subject to, so that fewer banks would be subject to all three tests. But the reality for that, as an example, is that even if you’re not required to report on a lot of things, you still may be required to produce that data in an exam setting. And so it may sound like a big burden reduction that you’re not reporting X, Y, Z, but you’re still going to be asked for it. So the data collection requirements aren’t changing for most institutions. And for the largest banks, we even see increased data collection and reporting requirements when it comes to that investment test, right? So more collection about what organizations you’re sending money to, how they’re using their funds, things like that. So maybe the proposal’s a little more than meets the eye at the moment.

Rebecca Escario: Yeah, I totally echo that, agree with that. Despite the fact that there might be a little bit less “regulatory burden,” if you will (we hear that phrase tossed around), it doesn’t take away from the fact that those facts don’t still need to be there to support a bank’s CRA narrative, to support their whole picture, if you will. So certainly don’t abandon any aspects of your program, especially if they are very helpful in telling your story and getting you the rating that you currently are getting. So certainly that.

Abby Hogan: Yeah. When you think about the proposed rule, do you think it’s on balance an improvement for communities, for the industry? Do you think there are winners or losers, or do you have any generalized feedback about how you’re thinking about the proposed rule?

Rebecca Escario: Yeah, and I think it depends on who’s thinking about it, whether the opinion is, “Are we a winner or loser?” et cetera. Some of the things that popped out to us were what you hit on, the asset-size threshold changes. So the smaller banks, or the banks that are moving into the smaller examination category, could be thinking, “We’re a winner here, because this is going to perhaps lower compliance costs. It’s going to afford us more flexibility,” again, that regulatory burden and reporting requirements. So I think in some ways you consider that a win. We hear there are a lot of challenges for these community banks with the cost of compliance, so that may help.

In a way, I think some of what’s in the rule is going to allow a little more predictability, if you will, for banks that have to date felt uncertainty, and there are unpredictable things about being examined under the CRA. Those could be considered wins for some of the smaller banks. I know there’s pushback to this as well, not getting too far ahead, and there are valid arguments for and against things.

Another thing that popped out for us, where it might be a little bit of a loser for some banks, is the grant rules, the new grants where that 15% can’t exceed for the overhead. We do work with a lot of community banks (larger banks as well, but a lot of community banks), and I know what the public feedback has been a little bit, but we’re also hearing this very personally from many of our clients: that could basically eliminate many of those for any CRA qualification. And what we see is just that a grant could be small. It doesn’t need to be a huge grant made by a much bigger bank, or even a huge grant made by a smaller bank. We often don’t see a direct correlation between the size of the grant and the impact it has on the community. You could have a much lower-volume grant where it’s going to exceed that 15% threshold, but it has such a positive impact on the community. It’s really meeting needs in the community. That’s going to be interesting to see if anything changes with that aspect of the new rule.

Abby Hogan: Yeah, that’s one that I think a lot of folks were surprised to see, in this discourse about reducing regulatory burden and making it a little bit easier for the industry to do the right thing. But then adding that grant requirement, I think, is going to be such a hurdle for a lot of institutions as written. So we’ll see.

Rebecca Escario: Yeah. And if there were anything to change, we’ve been thinking about that too, what might change. That’s one area we’re thinking may have some changes before this gets across the finish line. And maybe even the asset-size threshold categorizations could shift a little more before it becomes final final.

Abby Hogan: If you were the rule writer right now, Rebecca, if you had the pen and got to change anything you wanted, and you didn’t have to deal with any directives from higher-ups, what would you add, modify, change here?

Rebecca Escario: That’s a really ideal world, right? Didn’t have to deal with any objectives from any higher-ups. That sounds like utopia.

Abby Hogan: Queen for a day.

Rebecca Escario: But yeah, we’ve thought about this too. In the best-case scenario, I’ll just go back. I think one thing that we would change would be what we feel is a little bit (I don’t want to use too strong of words here) a little bit of a rigid cutoff with the grant proportionality standard there, because I do think there could be losers in that case if that completely sticks.

Again, asset-size thresholds, we might tweak them a little bit. We’ve seen public commentary. The cutoff date was just last week, I think, and there’s definitely been significant public commentary on it from the ABA, American Bankers Association. We have the National Community Reinvestment Coalition that came out with their big statement or letter on it. That was really interesting. And they cited these things too: the grant cutoffs, the asset-size thresholds, deposit access. We haven’t really touched on that yet. That’s another thing. I don’t know, Abby, if you’ve had a lot of conversations with others in the industry about that, how there’s seemingly so much more concentration or focus on lending, steering away a little bit from the deposit access piece.

Abby Hogan: Yeah, we’ve talked about a lot of the credit builder products that touch on that split, like the secured cards. A lot of really helpful, good products are straddling that gap. So certainly something we’ve discussed a bit there: just because it’s not credit doesn’t mean it’s not helpful for communities.

Rebecca Escario: Well, yes, I agree completely. And we see that’s really where a lot of banking customers in traditionally, perhaps, low- to moderate-income areas, underserved communities, enter the banking system altogether. And that gives them almost the stepping stone, the relationship with a lender, to get to that homeownership, American dream, get that mortgage. And so when you’re really taking away the importance of that being a community credit need as well, to get that entry point into the banking system via the deposit access products, those very valuable products, that really has us scratching our heads a little bit. And so if I was writing the rule, which I would not, but if I was writing the rule, that’s something I’d take a closer look at, and probably not skew it as much as it seems like the current proposed rulemaking does.

But again, I think we all just have to come to this with an open mind right now, thinking that it probably will undergo some changes. I mean, crazier things have happened, we know. But it probably will. That would be another area that I think, if we were writing the rule, we’d probably make some tweaks to.

Abby Hogan: Yeah, I tend to agree. I think a lot’s going to happen between now and any type of rule finalization, if we even get there. To your point, so many different organizations have submitted comment letters that are pretty critical. And so if the rule proposal isn’t changed, there’s also the Federal Reserve element here. So this is only an FDIC-OCC proposed rule. We don’t have the Federal Reserve Board online. And if the rule is finalized in its current form, I think there are so many legal challenges that are going to just land here that could delay this thing further. So the odds of this thing being finalized as is are pretty slim, and if so, it would take quite a while, I think.

Rebecca Escario: Yes. I agree definitely with that, and you bring up a point that we’ve talked quite a bit about as well: the Fed is not aligned yet with this proposed rulemaking, for multiple reasons, we can only assume. We know some technical, just how they can improve things internally takes longer. But I think there’s also a little bit of not quite being aligned with everything that this rulemaking has. And I think that’s going to be critical. I’m not sure anything will get finalized without that alignment, nor do we think it should. I can’t imagine that similarly situated banks are going to have different expectations from different agencies, all under CRA.

Abby Hogan: Yeah, can you imagine?

Rebecca Escario: I think it totally defies, goes against the whole purpose and objective of the Community Reinvestment Act, making it more difficult to meet the needs of communities because of conflicting regulatory expectations. That’s just silly. I just think it’s silly. But again, we’ll see.

Abby Hogan: Yeah, that would make it harder for everyone involved: the financial institutions, the regulators, the communities. If there are two sets of parallel rules for CRA compliance, we’re not setting ourselves up for success there.

Rebecca Escario: No, not at all.

Abby Hogan: So I guess I’ve had my discussion points here about the rule, but I’d love to hear what we’re not thinking about. What are some of the perspectives or topics, when everyone’s talking about CRA these days, that are going undiscussed or that need a little bit more time in the limelight?

Rebecca Escario: What are we not talking about? As an industry, as a whole, what maybe we’re not focusing on as much as we should be as we work our way through this? Well, I think a lot of things are being covered. I think a lot of people are talking about all of the important things, like we’ve talked about today. One thing we haven’t talked about yet on this podcast is the strategic plan component, because we saw the OCC come out with guidance on this in December of last year, and we thought it was very refreshing to see that. And then we see strategic plan accessibility and feasibility as part of this new proposed rulemaking, in slightly different form, a little bit more detail, slightly different nuances.

We’ve been talking to clients more and more about strategic plans, and we’re happy to see that piece in this proposed rulemaking. Perhaps that should be talked about a little bit more, because we’re getting a lot of questions, especially from our community bank partners and clients. We’ve really forged forward very quickly into the digital age and online applications, and defined assessment areas aren’t quite what they used to be under CRA. We have a lot of smaller institutions who are national lenders because of the online channel. And we have a lot of smaller lenders who have slightly different business models, especially with these bank-fintech partnerships that are all the rage these days. So they don’t exactly fit into the mold of the traditional tests: lending, service, investment. And so for these lenders to be able to craft their own goals according to strategic plans, based on their models, based on their perhaps slightly more unique lending models than their geographic peers, that could really open up a big door, we think, to enable them to better serve the needs of all the different communities that they serve.

So that’s just something that I think maybe deserves a little more discussion and focus as well. I know everyone’s talking about the grant limits, the asset thresholds, all of that, because we are too. Don’t get me wrong, we just did. But shining light on one really positive thing I think could come out of this rulemaking would be the accessibility to cast the net much wider for institutions to go this strategic plan [route], right?

Abby Hogan: That’s a great call-out. The strategic plans have been a fascinating little rabbit hole to dig into, and a lot of these are public too. So it’s very easy to go out there and find the banks that have strategic plans right now and how they approach that. Some of them are pretty sophisticated; some are trying to keep it as simple as possible. So, great call-out on that one.

So I think that’s all we have time for today, but thank you so much for joining us on the podcast, Rebecca. Looking forward to continuing the conversation about CRA, fair lending, and more as we keep running into CrossCheck down the road. So thank you for joining us.

Rebecca Escario: Absolutely. Thank you for having me. Really enjoyed it. Thanks so much.

Abby Hogan: Okay, take care.

Ready to get more out of your models?

Join leading financial institutions in deploying better AI faster.

Schedule a DemoChat With Us